33 Comments

On point #11: Decline of cohort-based learning

Would you say the parallel trend is the rise of homeschooling as the Department of Education is dismantled and schooling becomes state-controlled?

There might be the emergence of a TikTok subculture centered around homeschool moms.

Expand full comment

This list is stacked with truth. Clarification: what are some examples of self-critical wokeness? We’ve KINDA seen it with some recent post-election coverage (VERY lightly), but did you have some books in mind?

Expand full comment
author

No books, but I notice a lot of essays on Substack for example of people who are woke, but self-reflective about its implications

Expand full comment

Gotcha. I was wondering if this could include books like Musa Al-Gharbi’s We’ve Never Been Woke or Freddie DeBoer’s How the Elites Ate the Social Justice Movement. I wouldn’t call either of them “woke” but I do see them as more sophisticated/reflective in their critiques than obviously figures like Dave Rubin or Gad Saad or James Lindsay.

Expand full comment
Nov 9Liked by Katherine Dee

"Pushback against the medicalization of everyday life "

Yet the new glp1 obesity drugs are in continued high demand and showing no signs of slowing down.

Expand full comment
Nov 9Liked by Katherine Dee

What I’m taking away: the only thing more deeply rooted than contrarian reactionary posturing is witchcraft aesthetics. It really humbles you

Expand full comment
Nov 9Liked by Katherine Dee

I thought Amish people seemed cooler and even aspirational back in 2008! I must be ahead of the times.

Expand full comment
author

I've always loved them too. In a way, my love of Mormons created the "Default Friend" persona.

Expand full comment

Is it an explicit or implicit Mormon connection with the concept of the default friend? Is it that they are friendly as a default, or almost as a commandment?

Expand full comment

This one for instance: “People will be excited about Gavin Newsom” maybe there’s a popularity survey? I’m not saying you’re wrong just that I see a lot of these as arguable in either direction. Even the ones you said you got wrong

Expand full comment
author

You’re right. Like his favorability is low but he’s also highly memed

Expand full comment
author

So which one counts? It’s too broad to count

Expand full comment

Or this one: Renewed interest in Marshall McLuhan. I seem to remember peaks of interest periodically over the last 25 years.

Expand full comment
Nov 9Liked by Katherine Dee

One of the most respected people in my professional sphere is on year two of an application-only seminar series with the McLuhan institute.

Not sure how you “quantify” that, but people with professional influence in creative industries are paying attention.

Expand full comment

Quantifying things like that isn't too difficult - it's counting citations or Google Trends searches. https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=Marshall%20McLuhan&hl=en-US

Expand full comment
author

Thank you! McLuhan is becoming what Lasch and Paglia were 2018-2022

Expand full comment
author

Also I gotta ask Andrew about this seminar series!!!

Expand full comment
Nov 9Liked by Katherine Dee

This is it: https://kleinkleinklein.com/understanding-media-seminar

Would definitely sign-up if you ran something similar! It filled up fast.

Expand full comment
author

OH hey! He's a very cool guy.

Expand full comment

This one might be right: Trend toward miniature houses.

Expand full comment
author

That one is verifiably wrong, they’re favorable but very few ppl actually live in them

Expand full comment

Sure but “trend towards” just means more people live in them than when you made the prediction.

Expand full comment
author

True, can find interest growth but no good # on whether ppl actually live in them. I would also imagine no bc you need $$ for the land to put them on

Expand full comment
author

It’s a good humility check either way, it’s possible they’re all bull shit & who cares - as long as ppl don’t think I take it too seriously

Expand full comment

How do you quantify most of these.

Expand full comment
author

Many of them are measurable through analytics, checking headlines, etc.

Expand full comment

Some of them seem pretty straightforward but most don’t - but maybe you ran the numbers?

Expand full comment
author

What’s an example of one you disagree with or seems unquantifiable?

Expand full comment
author

I say "checking headlines" bc so many of these are just predictions about what conversations we're going to be having

Expand full comment
Nov 9Liked by Katherine Dee

Don't you think the "woke" vs. "anti-woke" divide is decreasing?

Expand full comment
author

Maybe it is, should I count that one as a win?

Expand full comment
Nov 9Liked by Katherine Dee

I think after this election, with woke calling out a different kind of woke, it has lost all relevance. I mean it's all like "Are you the Kamala lost because US hates women" woke or "Both are war criminals" woke? You should definitely count it as a win.

Expand full comment
author

Good point, tbh.

Expand full comment