Discussion about this post

User's avatar
DeepLeftAnalysis🔸's avatar

I was genuinely impressed with this post because of how easily, simply, and convincingly it refutes space colonization. For that alone, I give it an A+. Then it gets into the philosophy of superintelligence, and questions of will and desire for a self-modifying organism. This was fascinating, and encourages me to read more Spinoza, Schopenhauer, and Nietzsche, who are the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit of Darwinian philosophy. Nietzsche, of course, is the least important, but he has been given to the masses as the most apparent form of Darwinian philosophy. Darwin himself wasn’t a philosopher, but one who applied the philosophy to an empirical study and theorized about the precise mechanism of evolution. I recommend everyone read this piece, so we can move beyond silly sci-fi and get into philosophy, which is the root and crown of human civilization.

Laurie McAndish King's avatar

Lots to think about here; thank you!

One part I didn't follow:

"There’s an implicit ethics here: potential creates obligation (“with great power comes great responsibility!”). The Supercharacter’s ethics isn’t imposed from outside by a social contract or by the need for collective survival. It emerges from the logic of its own fulfillment."

In our culture, potential creates obligation, but how can we assume it would be an imperative for Supercharacter?

21 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?